Skip to content

When A Teen Goes Green

About an eco-positive lifestyle

Menu
  • Home
    • What is an eco-positive lifestyle?
    • New? Start here!
  • How to guides
  • Reducing negative impact
    • Veganism
    • Minimalism
    • Zero Waste
    • Sustainable Traveling
    • Sustainable and Fair Fashion
    • Intersectional Feminism
    • Circular Economy
    • The 9 Planetary Boundaries
  • Increasing positive impact
  • Inspiration
    • Recipes
    • Hotspots
    • Organizations and apps
    • Books, documentaries, films, series and podcasts
    • Books, Films and Series List
  • Personal
    • My Ideal World
    • About me and this blog
Menu

Why biomass is not a sustainable fuel

Posted on October 24, 2022January 22, 2023

This title that I wrote is pretty controversial, because it needs some nuance. And I’ll give that in a minute, I promise. But overall, I dare to say that my personal opinion on biomass is that it’s not a sustainable fuel. In my ideal world we’d need very little to no fuel created by biomass. Today I want to tell you how I came to that conclusion. Here’s why biomass is not a sustainable fuel.

What is Biomass

The definition of biomass is: a collective name for all material that has a plant-based or animal-based origin. Shit, that’s almost anything on this planet. From trees and leaves, to corn and wool. And that is true, biomass is a very broad term. However, today I’m talking about using biomass as a fuel. The most commonly used materials for biomass are wood or any type of grains. This biomass fuel is made by either burning, vaporizing or fermenting biomass.

Net Zero

Most people would probably think that I do not find biomass a sustainable fuel, because it creates greenhouse gases like CO2 and methane. But this is actually not the argument I’m making today, since using biomass as a fuel creates net zero emissions. Why? Well, let’s say we use wood (or any plant material) for production. In the lifetime of the tree, when it grows, it takes up CO2. That’s the reason why we need trees to combat climate change!

However, we then need to leave those trees be to actually do something about climate change. Because if we burn the trees, the tree releases the CO2 again, creating net zero emissions. The tree takes up CO2 first, but then releases this same amount again when it’s burnt. Net zero.

Animal-Based

Also, there’s also animal products, like manure, wool, etc. However, as a vegan I don’t support using animals for our own use. Even if that animal-based biomass is a rest product. And if it’s not a rest product, that would mean we’d breed animals to take their wool and shit, in the end. As I said, I am against using animals in general, but I also think this would create a messed up system like the factory farming we have today for their flesh.

Anyway, back to the first conclusion: using biomass a a fuel can be net zero. And that’s only the case if the biomass fuel producer also regrows the plant material. Still, the net zero argument does not mean using biomass as a fuel is a good idea. Here’s why biomass is not a sustainable fuel.

Pollution from burning

Lets first assume we’d create fuel from burning biomass directly. This emits CO2. But that is not one of the problems I have with using biomass as a fuel. I’ll explain that below. The first problem I have with burning biomass is the pollution. Next to the greenhouse gases, there are also other things which are emitted. Unhealthy material like root, smoke and particulate matter. We don’t want these things in the air.

But let’s assume we’d vaporize or ferment to make biomass fuel. The argument of pollution then still stands, as the proces of vaporizing or fermenting makes biogas. This biogas would then be burned to get the fuel and the same harmful substances will be released. Other renewable resources do not have this pollution, as the production proces can be made clean. This can’t be done when it comes to using biomass as a fuel.

Space

The next point is the space we’d need to create fuel made from biomass. Let’s say the pollution argument is not valid, just hypothetically. Then the biomass is a net zero fuel, right? And it’s renewable, because you can always regrow trees. Yes, but we’d need an immense amount of space to grow this biomass. If you install solar panels, you can do that on a roof, space that is not used anyway. However, when we use biomass, we need massive fields of agricultural land for that.

I guess you have not missed this, but there are a lot of people who are starving. One in four people globally are moderately or severely food insecure. I know this issues has to do with power structures and capitalism, but still. Isn’t it messed up to grow food on a massive scale and then burn it, while millions of people are starving? And it’s not even a necessity, we have many alternatives to using biomass as a fuel. We do not need to burn biomass to create fuel. I would argue it’s cruel to do this, we should use the land otherwise.

Ideals

I want to take it a step further, because I just said something about hunger. We can even go past that argument. Even if nobody on the planet would suffer from hunger, I’d still argue we should use the land differently. The massive amount of land we’d need for fuel made from biomass (since a country like the Netherland uses a lot of energy), we could also use for nature. Just leaving the land alone and letting nature and animals thrive. That would be highly beneficial for biodiversity. And even if the biodiversity was not an issue (I wish!), we should still value nature in itself. As a human species, it’s time to realize that the earth is not only ours.

Rest product

I believe most people think that fuel made from biomass is only made from rest material. Rest products from the wood industry, from the animal industry, from the food industry, etc. That argument is simply not true. We grow biomass just for to burn it. And yes, there’s also a part that’s produced from rest products. But that’s just a tiny part of the whole.

Haha, but there I am again. Even if we’d only make fuel out of biomass that is a rest product, I’d still argue that we should use these rest products differently. From the organic waste from households we could make compost to feed the land. Then we wouldn’t need all this polluting manure we have from animals. This goes for the organic waste from all commercial sectors as well. But we could also use it for other purposes. We could make furniture from the rest products from wood production. We could make isolation material from leftover cotton. Etc. The list goes on.

Alternatives

With all the arguments I listed above, I honestly don’t see why we still consider using biomass for fuel. In the Netherlands, biomass is actually the biggest share of renewable energy. I don’t understand. We have so many great, sustainable other options. Solar panels, wind mills, geothermal plants or hydropower. Some of these alternatives are also very cheap, like solar panels. If I envision my ideal society of 2050, using biomass as a fuel is not in there. I hope more people envision this same future.

Yours sincerely,
Romee

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search for anything

Want to get an update every time I post something?

Enter your email address to subscribe to my blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 268 other subscribers.

ABOUT ME

 

Hi! My name is Romee Hoeksma and I am on a journey to an eco-positive life. An eco-positive lifestyle is a lifestyle in which I have a more positive than negative impact on the beautiful planet earth. On this blog you can follow my journey to a life with only positive impact. At this blog you can find all sorts of things, from tips to recipes to personal experiences, but most of all fun (I hope!). I write about how I want to change the world, but don’t look at it as if I’m judging you. If anything, I like responses from my dear readers the most, so don’t hesitate to contact me or respond to any of my posts!

Yours sincerely,
Romee

Here’s what I posted most recently

  • Femicide
  • Vegan food diary for a week – March 2023
  • Are charities the solution to our problems?
  • Documentary: Disclosure
  • Vegan restaurants in London

Translate this site

Follow me on Instagram

Eén van mijn favoriete vegan snacks, bij de Lidl tijdens de Griekse week 🇬🇷. Op dit moment is plantaardig eten nog niet de norm in Nederland, helaas. Daarom hebben veel mensen dan ook geen idee wat veganisten eten. Om die reden heb ik de afgelopen week weer eens een eetdagboek bijgehouden, want wat eet ik nou als veganist gedurende de week? Je leest het nu in mijn vegan food diary via de link in mijn bio 🥭. #plantaardig #veganfood #dagboek Verpakkingsvrij wasmiddel kopen, dat hoeft niet moeilijk te zijn! In deze reel laat ik je zien hoe ik dat doe 🧺. Volg mijn account voor meer duurzame tips. Elke maand doneer ik ongeveer 7% van mijn inkomen aan goede doelen, omdat ik dat zie als enorm belangrijk en het juiste ding om te doen 💸. Maar daarmee komt de vraag op: geloof ik dat goede doelen het antwoord zijn op alle grote problemen van onze tijd? Oftewel: is geld doneren de oplossing? Over die vraag én het antwoord schreef ik een uitgebreid artikel die vandaag online staat, de link vind je in mijn bio. #goeddoel #doneren #blog Vegan pizza tonno, hmmmm. Dacht je dat vegans geen tonijnpizza kunnen eten? Think again! 🐟 Een hele tijd geleden schreef ik een artikel over e-mail activisme: een vorm van activisme die je thuis op de bank kan doen. Vandaag deel ik graag een geslaagd voorbeeld daarvan met jullie ✨. Vandaag staat er een documentaire-tip op mijn blog. Disclosure, een documentaire over de representatie van transgender personen in de media 📽. Echt een must-see, want wat wij hebben als cis-gender personen nog een hoop te leren. Lees meer over de documentaire via de link in mijn bio. #disclosure #documentaire #transgender Vandaag deel 2 van de vegan hotspots in Londen 🧆. Wat heb ik lekker gegeten daar, niet te doen! Bubala was mijn absolute favoriet, dus als je iets moet kiezen, kies Bubala. Vorige week verscheen er een artikel over treinreizen naar Londen op mijn blog. Aanvullend daarop verscheen er vandaag een artikel over een ander aspect van duurzaam reizen: het eten. Lees nu het artikel met mijn favoriete veganistische restaurants in Londen nu via de link in mijn bio 🌮. #veganfood #veganlondon #veganrestaurants

Read my latest posts

  • Femicide
  • Vegan food diary for a week – March 2023
  • Are charities the solution to our problems?
  • Documentary: Disclosure
  • Vegan restaurants in London

Subscribe by e-mail

©2023 When A Teen Goes Green | WordPress Theme by Superbthemes.com