It’s only the beginning of June, but summer has already started in The Netherlands. We’ve had multiple days over 30 degrees Celsius. I can bare heat very well, but my partner struggles with it. And we’ve been struggling to keep our house cool. We live in an apartment (about 60 m2) on the top floor with a flat roof in the middle of the city (Utrecht). This summer we’re ready to take some measures against the heat. When it comes to these measures, most people think about airconditioning for cooling. But that’s not what we’re planning on doing to make our home cooler. Here’s why I don’t want airconditioning in my home.
Refrigerant agents
You’d think that airconditioning is a sustainable choice if you have solar panels, or renewable energy in general. But airconditioning needs more than just electricity to function. Aside from the energy, airconditioning needs refrigerant agents to make cool air. Recently I wrote an article about Stratospheric Ozone Depletion, in which I explained that some refrigerant agents cause the ozone hole. The most harmful refrigerant agents (CFC’s or HCFC’s) have been banned or will be banned in the coming years, causing the ozone hole to recover.
Right now, we use refrigerant agents which do not harm the ozone (HCF’s). But that doesn’t mean they’re harmless. HFC’s have a huge global warming potential, about 2000 thousand times higher than CO2. However, we have a solution that is better in that aspect as well: natural refrigerants. Natural refrigerants are not harmful to the ozone ánd they have a lower global warming potential than HCF’s. So they’re less harmful. But they’re not harmless. Up to this day, we have no refrigerant agents which are harmless.
Global warming of natural refrigerants
So most refrigerants are no sustainable options because they cause global warming. But like I said, we have natural refrigerants as an alternative. Usually, when I consider if I find something sustainable or not, I try to find out what happens when everybody on the planet does the same thing (as that would be fair/ethical). As far as I could find, all refrigerants agents leak at some point (the average is about 1%). If everyone of the planet has a airconditioning with a natural refrigerant (for example CO2, which is a natural refrigerant), that would be a leakage of 12.5 million kilograms of CO2 each year (12500 tonnes). This is the equivalent of the emissions of a small city. Note: I couldn’t find anywhere how much CO2 as a refrigerant agents goes into airconditioning systems, so I asked an open-source AI model for this, Olmo. It might be wrong, but it gives an indication.
The planetary boundary for climate change is set at 350 parts of CO2 per million parts in the atmosphere. In 2023 we were at 419 parts per million. So if we want to keep this earth habitable for humans, we can’t emit any more CO2 until we’re back below the planetary boundary again. So the coming decades airconditioning is not a sustainable option. When we manage to get below the 350 parts per million again (hopefully soon), it might be sustainable. 12500 tonnes of CO2 means an increase of 0,000006 parts per million per year, which is neglect able (as it would take 167 years to get from 350 to 351 part per million with 12500 tons of CO2 emissions per year).
Renewable origin of natural refrigerants
Besides the global warming caused by refrigerants, it’s also true that refrigerant agents can only be made from biomass in a sustainable way. Generally speaking, there are three natural refrigerants: propane (R290), isobutane (R600a) and CO2. If these substances are used as refrigerants, they need to be renewable because refrigerants leak and so will need to be refilled endlessly. Right now, we have no really good options to produce propane, isobutane or CO2 with renewable resources as the only option is with biomass. In an ideal world, we’d have a 100% circular economy so this biomass can’t be a waste stream and so we’d need to sacrifice land to produce this biomass.
If we assume that 12500 tonnes of CO2 (the refrigerant agent) leak from airconditioning systems, we’d need about 1250 hectares of land to produce that same CO2 from biomass to refill the leakages. This is the equivalent of two small villages. That seems doable. However, personally, I feel that land can be better used for nature to thrive (since we’re in a biodiversity crisis).
Energy use
Besides the aspect of refrigerant agents, there’s the energy use. Airconditioning devices use a lot of energy, especially the mobile ones. The energy use of airconditioning is about 20 times higher than that of a ventilating fan. If you don’t have renewable energy (from your own solar panels or your energy supplier), a higher energy use is always bad for the environment as we use fossil fuels for this energy. If you do have renewable energy to power your airconditioning, one might say that there’s no environmental impact. Simply put this is true. However, I’d say there are two arguments for using as little energy as possible, even if you use renewable energy.
We need renewable energy for essentials
The first one would be that right now, we need to do everything we can to combat climate change since we’re far over the planetary boundary already (which is causing the earth to warm up). We don’t have enough renewable energy right now to do all the essential things we absolutely need (like heating our homes and transporting ourselves). I would therefore argue that it’s unethical to use energy for airconditioning as long as we haven’t made sure that we’re within the planetary boundary of climate change, as airconditioning is comfortable and luxurious, but not essential.
In the future, when we’ve managed to keep climate change within the planetary boundary, the energy use of airconditioning might not be realistic either. Considering different climates and uses, an airconditioning uses about 1500 kilowatt hours a year, with the current people inhabiting the earth (8 billion divided by 2 because a lot of people live together but population will grow), this means an energy use of 6000 Terrawatt hours for airconditioning alone. Our current electricity use is 28000 Terrawatt hours on a global level. If we’d need 6000 Terrawatt hours extra, that would mean an increase in electricity use of about 20%. I don’t know the exact components of solar panels and wind mills, but I doubt if we have enough materials to built all these for 6000 Terrawatt hours for airconditioning purposes only.
The more energy we need, the more materials we need
Renewable energy is not made from fossil fuels, which is amazing. However, we do need to take something from the earth in order to produce this renewable energy. And this ‘something’ are (sometimes critical) materials. For solar panels or wind turbines, we need materials (metal, silicon etc.). Right now, we have no ways to produce those materials in a sustainable way. Mining is harmful and so are most production processes. So as long as we haven’t found clean production processes for these materials, it’s best to keep them in the ground, which means we should strive to need as little of them as possible.
If we’ve managed to make the production processes of these materials sustainable and we’ve mined all of them sustainable and there are enough materials available to do everything we consider essential ánd have enough left, then it might be okay. At that point, we have an x amount of each material, which we would recycle endlessly. So in that way, this aspect could be sustainable. But I don’t see it happening anytime soon and I also doubt if we have enough materials.
Airconditioning systems make a circular economy difficult
Aside from the refrigerant agents and energy use, airconditioning makes a circular economy a lot harder, if not impossible. If you interpreter a circulair economy as have no waste, then airconditioning isn’t. That’s because, like we’ve seen before, the refrigerant agents leak and won’t be reused. You lose them and need to produce something new to make the system work again. This proces is linear. But like we’ve seen in the section about the refrigerant agents, this fact alone doesn’t have to be bad. The real downside is that as a society as a whole we need more human activity to keep it going (production of new refrigerant agents). It’s the question whether we want to spend our time on this, when societies are shrinking and we already have difficulties to keep have enough people to keep education and health care systems going. The latter are essentials, airconditioning is not.
As far as I could find, airconditioning systems are not 100% recyclable right now. If it’s impossible to make them 100% recyclable, they can’t be circular and can never be sustainable in my eyes. If they are, then I do know that the recycling proces is quite difficult because of the refrigerant agents. You can’t just do anything you want with airconditioning, as the refrigerant agents might leak. You need specialized people to maintain, recycle or replace these systems. The consequence is that you can’t really built a secondhand market for it, as it’s not safe them to bring them to a thrift shop and be installed by individuals. You’d need a specialized industry which collects, checks and re-installs airconditioning systems in that case (we don’t have such a market right now). Like I said before, in a society in which workers are scarce I could think of better ways to spend our time.
The contradiction with a ventilation fan is big. You can do whatever you want with a fan. You can repair it yourself (or bring it to a repair café), bring it to a thrift shop yourself and they can be made 100% recyclable (with the right materials). In my ideal society, we’d repair items endlessly until we die and then the stuff we used to own will be passed on to others and so essentially anything we buy will be secondhand. With fans this is very well doable. With airconditioning this is not the case.
Airconditioning replaces sustainable solutions
If we want to keep our homes cool, there are many sustainable solutions to do so. Good isolation is the first step (which also helps us save energy during winter). After that, it’s best to make sure the sun doesn’t directly reach your home. You can do this either by surrounding your home with trees, plants and bushes, which also enhance biodiversity and take up water and therefore prevent flooding. Aside from that the sun doesn’t directly reach your home, plants also cool the air in general. Another way to make sure the sun doesn’t reach your home directly is by installing sunscreens. These can be made 100% recyclable with sustainable materials and don’t use any energy. If you want even more cooling, you could use fans. All these measures together make a really comfortable home in which you won’t need airconditioning.
We don’t need airconditioning
This might actually might be the main reason why I don’t want airconditioning in my home: they’re not essential. For most people airconditioning is a luxury. At least for me it would be. I don’t need airconditioning to survive or be healthy. It’s basically a luxury for me, it provides comfort. There might be groups of people for which green surroundings, sunscreens and fans aren’t enough to survive (some elderly or sick people), then it’s a completely different story of course. But for me it’s not essential.
In a way, it’s also a lazy solution. If I don’t want to invest in greening the area around my house, installing sunscreens and using a fan, I can just use an airconditioning instead. One press on a button and the house is cooled. In addition to that, airconditioning systems are used very little. In the Netherlands, the average use is 20 days per year. That means that the airconditioning isn’t used for the remaining 345 days of the year. I think if you use something so little, it’s a luxury and not a necessity.
You move the hot air to others
The basic principle of airconditioning is that you remove the heat from your home and that it’s released outside. From a community’s point of view, this is quite selfish. During hot days, everybody wants to keep cool. Your house might be cool if you use airconditioning, but your heat is basically sent to your neighbors (especially in cities). That means they would struggle even more to keep cool (studies show that airconditioning worsens the urban heat island effect). Airconditioning is an individual solution. And therefore it also diverts from finding collective solutions, like reducing the amount of concrete in your street and replacing it with green.
Those are my reasons for why I don’t want airconditioning in my home right now. It’s a nuanced story with many details and therefore not very straightforward, but for me it gives a good indication.
Yours sincerely,
Romee